The Miracle at Brookline: Reliving the Greatest Comeback in Ryder Cup History

---

id: 69 title: The Miracle at Brookline: Reliving the Greatest Comeback in Ryder Cup History

September 26, 1999, dawned with Team Europe holding a commanding 10-6 lead at The Country Club in Brookline, Massachusetts. Europe needed just 4 points from 12 singles matches to retain the Ryder Cup. American captain Ben Crenshaw faced what seemed an impossible task. What unfolded over the next six hours would become the most dramatic comeback in Ryder Cup history—a day that would forever be known as 'The Miracle at Brookline.'

The Impossible Position

No team had ever overcome a 10-6 deficit entering Sunday singles. The mathematics were daunting: Team USA needed 8.5 points from 12 matches—a winning percentage of over 70%. Europe's captain Mark James, confident in his team's position, could afford to be patient. His players simply needed to avoid a complete collapse.

But Ben Crenshaw never lost faith. At Saturday night's team meeting, he became emotional, telling his players he believed in them. "I'm going to leave you with one thought," Crenshaw said, his voice cracking with emotion. "I'm a big believer in fate. I have a good feeling about tomorrow."

The Strategic Lineup

Crenshaw's singles lineup was both bold and brilliant:

1. Tom Lehman vs. Lee Westwood
2. Hal Sutton vs. Darren Clarke
3. Phil Mickelson vs. Jarmo Sandelin
4. Davis Love III vs. Jean van de Velde
5. Tiger Woods vs. Andrew Coltart
6. David Duval vs. Jesper Parnevik
7. Mark O'Meara vs. Padraig Harrington
8. Steve Papp vs. Miguel Angel Jimenez
9. Jim Furyk vs. Sergio Garcia
10. Justin Leonard vs. José María Olazábal
11. Payne Stewart vs. Colin Montgomerie
12. Jeff Maggert vs. Paul Lawrie

Crenshaw front-loaded his lineup with proven winners, hoping early American red on the scoreboard would create momentum and pressure Europe's middle-order players.

The Tidal Wave Begins

From the first tee shot, American players attacked with ferocious intensity. The massive partisan crowd at The Country Club created a cauldron of noise, willing their team forward.

Tom Lehman set the tone with aggressive, fearless golf, defeating Lee Westwood 3&2. As Lehman walked off the 16th green victorious, he pointed to the sky, his emotion infectious.

Hal Sutton dispatched Darren Clarke 4&2, his bulldog mentality perfectly suited for the day's demands. "I wasn't going to lose," Sutton said afterward. "Not today."

Phil Mickelson overwhelmed Jarmo Sandelin 4&3, his birdie barrage too much for the Swede to handle.

Suddenly, the scoreboard blazed red. Three American points. Then four. Then five.

Davis Love III crushed Jean van de Velde 6&5 in one of the day's most dominant performances. Love's power game was simply overwhelming.

Tiger Woods, the world number one making his Ryder Cup debut, delivered a crucial point with a 3&2 victory over Andrew Coltart. Woods' fist pumps energized an already electric atmosphere.

The Turning Point: Duval's Dominance

David Duval, playing some of the finest golf of his career, demolished Jesper Parnevik 5&4. Duval made nine birdies in 14 holes, a performance so clinical it demoralized European hopes.

By mid-afternoon, the impossible was becoming possible. The scoreboard showed six American points already secured. The comeback was real.

The Pivotal Matches

As the later matches reached critical stages, three battles would determine the outcome:

Steve Papp vs. Miguel Angel Jimenez: The unheralded Papp, a captain's pick, delivered when it mattered most, winning 3&2. His emotional celebration showed what the Ryder Cup means to players who may only get one chance.

Jim Furyk vs. Sergio Garcia: The 19-year-old Spanish sensation battled magnificently, but Furyk's steady brilliance prevailed 4&3. Another American point.

Now the score stood at 13-13. One more American half-point would reclaim the Cup.

The Putt Heard Round the World

On the 17th green, Justin Leonard faced José María Olazábal in a match that epitomized the day's drama. Leonard trailed for most of the match but clawed back to all-square standing on the 17th tee.

Both players hit the par-3 green, but Leonard faced a treacherous 45-foot putt across severe undulations. Olazábal, much closer, appeared in control.

Leonard studied the line, seeing the breaks and slopes that would need to be navigated. He struck the putt with perfect pace. The ball rolled and rolled, breaking left, then right, tracking toward the hole like it was magnetized.

As the ball tumbled into the cup, The Country Club erupted. Leonard sprinted across the green, arms raised. American players, wives, caddies—everyone—rushed onto the green in celebration, one of the most iconic and controversial moments in Ryder Cup history.

(Olazábal still had his putt to halve the hole and keep the match alive, making the premature celebration a breach of etiquette. He would miss, effectively ending Europe's hopes.)

Leonard won 4&3, and the comeback was complete.

The Final Flourishes

The remaining matches became formalities:

Payne Stewart, in one of his final competitive rounds before his tragic death two months later, halved his match with Colin Montgomerie. In an act of pure sportsmanship, Stewart conceded Montgomerie's final putt to spare him from the hostile crowd.

Jeff Maggert defeated Paul Lawrie 3&2, adding an exclamation point to America's extraordinary day.

The final score: USA 14.5, Europe 13.5

Crenshaw's Tears

Ben Crenshaw, who had believed when belief seemed foolish, collapsed in tears on the 18th green. His wife Jan embraced him as decades of Ryder Cup passion poured out. "I had a belief," he sobbed. "I couldn't explain it. I just had a feeling."

The Controversy

The American celebrations, particularly the green-storming after Leonard's putt while Olazábal still had a putt remaining, created lasting controversy. European players felt disrespected. Mark James was furious. The incident prompted discussions about sportsmanship and decorum that continue today.

The Americans later issued apologies, acknowledging the breach of etiquette while maintaining the emotions of the moment were genuine and uncontrollable.

Statistical Impossibility Achieved

The numbers tell the story:

• 8.5 points from 12 singles matches—exactly what was needed
• American record: 8-3-1
• Only one American loss (Garcia over Furyk was halved)
• Average margin of victory: 3.5 holes

No European player won more than their match, and several stars failed to deliver when it mattered most.

Why the Comeback Succeeded

Crenshaw's Leadership: His emotional belief infected the team. Players later said they couldn't let down a captain who believed so completely.

Front-Loading Strategy: Putting proven winners early created immediate scoreboard pressure that snowballed.

Crowd Energy: The partisan Massachusetts crowd created an intimidating environment that rattled some European players.

American Aggression: Every player attacked the course and their opponents. There was no defensive golf, only relentless pressure.

European Complacency: With a four-point lead, some European players may have felt the Cup was already won, affecting their aggressive instincts.

Tactical Decisions: Mark James' decision to rest Sergio Garcia and Jesper Parnevik for Saturday afternoon fourballs was questioned, as both players might have extended Europe's lead.

The Legacy

The Miracle at Brookline changed the Ryder Cup:

1. No Lead is Safe: Teams no longer assume comfortable leads are secure. The 1999 comeback proved anything is possible in Sunday singles.

2. Momentum is Everything: The American wave of early points created unstoppable momentum that crushed European morale.

3. Captaincy Matters: Crenshaw's emotional leadership and strategic lineup showcased how much captains influence outcomes.

4. Controversy About Celebrations: The green-storming incident led to discussions about appropriate behavior and sportsmanship.

5. Increased Intensity: If possible, the Ryder Cup became even more intense after 1999, with both sides understanding that no match is over until it's over.

Lessons for Future Ryder Cups

For Teams Behind: Never surrender. The Miracle at Brookline proved that four points can evaporate in hours. Believe, fight, and attack.

For Teams Ahead: Protect the lead aggressively. Don't play conservative golf hoping opponents fail. Continue attacking to maintain pressure.

For Captains: Leadership and belief matter. Crenshaw's emotion and faith inspired his team to achieve the impossible.

For Players: Momentum is contagious. Early points energize teams and demoralize opponents. Every match matters.

Iconic Moments from the Day

Ben Crenshaw's Saturday Night Speech: His emotional prediction of victory set the tone.

Justin Leonard's 45-Footer: The putt that clinched the comeback and created controversy.

Payne Stewart's Sportsmanship: Conceding Montgomerie's putt to spare him from crowd abuse.

The Green-Storming: The chaotic, controversial celebration that became iconic.

Crenshaw's Tears: The captain's emotional release after his belief was vindicated.

Where Are They Now?

Many players from that historic day have remained connected to the Ryder Cup:

Justin Leonard: His putt remains the defining moment of his career.

Tiger Woods: Would go on to compile a 13-21-3 Ryder Cup record, never replicating his dominant singles performance from 1999.

Sergio Garcia: The 19-year-old rookie would become Europe's all-time leading points scorer with 28.5 points.

Payne Stewart: Tragically died in a plane crash just two months later, making his final Ryder Cup appearance even more poignant.

Phil Mickelson: Became a Ryder Cup stalwart with 12 appearances spanning 24 years.

The 25th Anniversary

In 2024, The Country Club hosted a 25th-anniversary celebration of the Miracle at Brookline. Players from both teams reunited, the passage of time softening the controversy. They shared stories, laughed about the chaos, and marveled at what they'd achieved and endured.

"It was the most intense day of my career," Justin Leonard reflected. "I've made bigger putts in majors, but nothing will ever match the emotion of that moment."

José María Olazábal added perspective: "It hurt terribly at the time. But looking back, we were part of something historic. The Ryder Cup is special because of days like that."

Conclusion: When the Impossible Became Reality

The Miracle at Brookline stands as the Ryder Cup's most dramatic comeback, a day when belief triumphed over mathematics, when emotion overwhelmed logic, and when twelve American golfers achieved what everyone said was impossible.

Ben Crenshaw's tears on the 18th green captured the essence of the Ryder Cup—passion that transcends the game itself, creating moments that define careers and captivate generations.

Twenty-five years later, the Miracle at Brookline remains the standard by which all comebacks are measured. It reminds us that in the Ryder Cup, with its unique format, passionate crowds, and team dynamics, no lead is safe and no deficit is insurmountable.

The scoreboard may show numbers, but the Ryder Cup is decided by belief, courage, and the refusal to surrender. On September 26, 1999, at The Country Club in Brookline, those qualities turned the impossible into reality.